What Does a Commercial Property Valuation Test? A Lender's View
Property Lending
Commercial valuation · Mortgage security · Lender's view
For business owners buying or refinancing commercial property: what the lender's valuer checks, how rent and leases affect the figure, what the report can do to your available loan, and what to do before signing, after a low valuation and at a later revaluation.
Quick Answer
A lender's commercial property valuation reports market value at a stated date and identifies the property and income risks that matter when the asset is used as loan security. The valuer tests sales evidence, market rent, leases, condition, use and likely marketing period; the lender then applies its own credit policy, gearing and servicing rules.
It is not automatically a forced-sale value, and the valuer does not decide how much you can borrow. If the accepted valuation is below the purchase price, the lower value can reduce the available loan and leave a cash or security shortfall.
Also called: bank valuation, mortgage security valuation, lender valuation. The first two are everyday names; a mortgage security valuation is the formal term for a report instructed by, and addressed to, the lender.
Where are you in the process?
Know the valuation risk before the contract clock starts.
Ask how the lender will value the property, who chooses the valuer, who pays, and whether a low figure could change the amount available. If you are signing a contract before valuation, ask your solicitor how the finance condition deals with a valuation shortfall. Then gather the documents in what to send before the inspection.
Make the inspection easy and the evidence complete.
Send the leases, rent roll and outgoings ahead of the visit, arrange access to every tenancy, and pass on any comparable sales or leasing evidence you know of. The valuer tests your lease against the market, as explained in how the valuer tests your lease.
Clear the conditions and ask for your copy.
Further reports the valuer recommends usually become conditions of approval, so order them early and check the report date against your settlement date. See what happens when the value holds.
A lower accepted value can reduce the available loan, so plan the gap now.
Your options are more of your own funds, a renegotiated price, additional security, a review with new evidence, or a lender whose policy fits the property better. See what to do if it comes in below the price.
Expect the building to be valued as if it were vacant.
A lease from one of your entities to your own business usually does not lift the value for lending. See how an owner-occupied building is valued.
What is a lender's commercial valuation actually testing?
A lender's commercial property valuation answers a narrower question than a buyer's feasibility: what is the property's market value at the valuation date, what evidence supports that value, and what property or income risks matter if it is taken as loan security. The report also gives an estimated marketing period. It does not decide whether the purchase is a good deal and it does not decide how much you can borrow.
The International Valuation Standards, which the Australian Property Institute adopts for this work, define market value as the estimated amount for which the property should exchange at the valuation date between a willing buyer and willing seller in an arm's-length transaction after proper marketing. For a lender, that value is an input into the security decision. The profession's guidance says lending remains the lender's commercial decision and a valuer should not generally recommend a maximum loan percentage or amount. The lender separately applies its own policy, LVR, servicing and conditions.
The lender instructs the valuer, either directly or through a third-party panel manager. Under the profession's guidance for mortgage and loan security work, instructions are ideally received from the lender, and a report the borrower orders cannot be relied on by a lender until the valuer consents in writing and issues a new report addressed to that lender. This is professional guidance for valuers, not law, and lender instructions vary. It matters most when the valuation is ordered under contract, because the report and your finance clause run on the same clock.
Can a low commercial valuation affect a subject-to-finance purchase?
Yes. A low valuation can affect finance without producing a simple loan decline: the lender may still approve the borrower but offer a smaller facility because the value it accepts is lower. A subject-to-finance condition does not have one universal effect across Australian commercial contracts, so do not assume a valuation shortfall automatically gives you a right to walk away. Before signing, have your solicitor or conveyancer check the wording, the required loan amount, the finance date and the notice steps, and make sure the valuation and formal approval timetable can realistically fit inside that period.
Is a bank valuation the same as market value?
Usually, the central figure in a mortgage security valuation is market value as at the valuation date, which will normally be the date of inspection. It is not supposed to be a deliberately reduced 'bank value'. If a lender wants a value on another basis, a special assumption, the valuer reports market value "as is" first, then describes the assumption, gives the value subject to it with supporting sales evidence, and comments on the difference. The other figure sits alongside market value, never in place of it. This is professional guidance, not law, and lender instructions can vary the basis, so the report states which one applies.
The valuer should also comment on any pending sale made known to them, and on any difference between the value and the sale price. Market value for mortgage security purposes also excludes sale incentives, such as cashbacks. That rule covers incentives on a sale only. Where the report and the contract price differ, the lender follows its report, which is why a bank won't simply lend against the price you agreed.
How is it different from an agent's appraisal?
An agent's appraisal is not a mortgage security valuation. It is a marketing or price opinion prepared by an agent; where a lender requires a formal security valuation, it relies on a valuation prepared or accepted under its own valuation process. A lender's valuation is prepared by a qualified valuer, addressed to the lender, and supported by the sales and rental evidence analysed in the report. For the basic terms, see our glossary entry on what a property valuation is.
| Report | Who orders it | Who can rely on it | The question it answers | What a lender does with it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agent appraisal or price opinion | The owner or an agent | Nobody, as a valuation | What might this sell for in the current market? | Treats it as background only |
| Market valuation ordered by the owner | The owner | The owner, for the stated purpose | What is it worth, for this purpose, at this date? | Cannot rely on it until the valuer consents in writing and reissues it to the lender |
| Mortgage security valuation | The lender | The lender named in the report | What is it worth as security, at this date, and what are the risks? | Sets the loan amount and conditions under its own policy |
| Value on a special assumption | The lender, only if it asks | The lender | What would it be worth if the stated assumption held? | Reads it next to market value as is, never instead of it |
Sources: Australian Property Institute, ANZVGP 112 Valuations for Mortgage and Loan Security Purposes ss3.0, 4.1, 4.2, 5.4, 5.6 and 5.8, issued 18 December 2024, effective 1 January 2025. Read 25 September 2026. Australian Property Institute, Valuation Process, last modified 3 November 2025. Read 25 September 2026.
Which standards does the valuer follow?
The valuer follows the Australian Property Institute's guidance for mortgage and loan security valuations, ANZVGP 112, effective from 1 January 2025, together with the International Valuation Standards. The valuer is typically a Certified Practising Valuer (CPV). The Australian Property Institute says its CPV certification is recognised by all major financial institutions as a prerequisite for access to valuation work, and applicants need an accredited course, two years of valuation experience and a report review and interview. The guidance tells the valuer what the report must address. It does not tell the lender what to lend.
Sources: Australian Property Institute, Certified Practising Valuer (CPV), last modified 10 March 2026. Read 25 September 2026.
Which methods does the valuer use?
A commercial valuer usually weighs three methods and explains in the report which one leads:
- Income capitalisation converts the net income the property can reliably earn into a value, using a capitalisation rate: the percentage that turns one year of net income into a capital value.
- Direct comparison weighs the property against recent sales of similar properties.
- Cost or summation adds the land value to the depreciated cost of the improvements.
Which method leads depends on the property type and the evidence available. On an income-producing property, a useful way to understand the capitalisation method is value = sustainable net income ÷ capitalisation rate. The valuer, not the borrower, decides the sustainable income and the market-supported rate, and will usually cross-check the result against sales evidence.
What does the valuer inspect at the property?
The inspection confirms the physical property the report is valuing and gives the valuer evidence that cannot be tested from a lease or sales database alone. Expect the valuer to check the site and improvements, access, apparent condition, current occupation and use, and anything visible that may affect marketability or require further investigation. The valuer then combines the inspection with title, planning, lease, sales and rental evidence; the inspection is not a building or environmental warranty.
The valuer flags the security risk; the relevant specialist determines the underlying problem. A valuer may identify uncertainty around zoning, lawful use, unauthorised works, fire or essential-services compliance, contamination, flooding, access, easements, title, heritage controls or building condition and recommend further investigation. That does not make the valuer the building consultant, environmental scientist, town planner or lawyer. The lender decides whether it needs a specialist report or legal/planning advice before it will rely on the property as security.
Which parts of the report decide how much you can borrow?
The valuation does not by itself set the loan. The lender uses the value it accepts together with the purchase or refinance structure, its maximum LVR, servicing and credit policy. A lower accepted valuation can reduce the amount available even when the borrower otherwise services the debt. Three parts of the report are especially important: the value and valuation basis, the risk analysis, and the estimated marketing period.
The valuer addresses the main risk issues. These can include market factors and property factors such as cashflow, planning, use, function, location, environmental and market risk, reported so the lender can assess the security. That describes what the report contains, not any lender's decision.
The valuer also reports the GST status and gives an estimated marketing period. The basis of value changes before any lease is read when your own business is the tenant.
Banks carry one more rule of their own. APRA's credit risk standard, APS 220, says "the valuation of collateral must reflect fair values, taking into account prevailing market conditions such as time taken for the liquidation or realisation of collateral." That applies to APRA-regulated banks and governs their own credit risk; it does not bind valuers or non-bank lenders.
The loan to value ratio is lender policy, not the valuer's number, and the maximum varies by lender and property type across commercial property loans. Lenders typically lend less against purpose-built or specialised property, because fewer buyers compete for it. Where a property is purpose-designed for one occupier and would not suit another, the guidance says the valuer should report both the value for that occupier and an alternative use value, so the lender sees both. If a lender wants a lower basis, such as a forced sale value, it has to ask for it, and the valuer reports it next to market value as is.
| Report section | What it records | What the lender does with it |
|---|---|---|
| Basis of value and assumptions | Market value as is, the date, and any instructed basis such as vacant possession or a special assumption | Checks that the basis matches what its policy lends against |
| Value | The valuer's figure and the evidence behind it | Uses the accepted value in its LVR and gearing calculation under its own policy; on a purchase, a lower value can reduce the amount available |
| Risk analysis | The main market and property risks the valuer sees | May add conditions, change gearing or decide the property falls outside policy, depending on the lender |
| Estimated marketing period | How long the valuer expects a sale to take | Weighs how quickly it could recover the loan |
| Lease and income summary | Leases, rents, expiry and outgoings the valuer relied on | Tests the security and durability of the property income; borrower serviceability is a separate lender assessment |
| Recommendations | Further reports or specialist checks the valuer suggests | May require building, environmental, planning, legal or other specialist work before it will rely on the security |
Sources: Australian Property Institute, ANZVGP 112 ss5.1, 5.3, 5.4, 5.5 and 5.8, issued 18 December 2024. Read 25 September 2026. APRA, Prudential Standard APS 220 Credit Risk Management para 49, in force 1 January 2023 (Federal Register text). Read 25 September 2026.
From the broker's desk: indicative, not a quote
The report comments that most often create extra credit work on an ordinary commercial property, in the order we see them: a long estimated marketing period; a material gap between passing rent and market rent; a short remaining lease that increases vacancy or re-letting risk; related-party occupation that changes the valuation basis; a moderate or higher risk rating on location or condition; and recommendations for further reports such as building, environmental or fire.
Indicative only, from Switchboard's own files as at September 2026. Every lender reads the report against its own policy, and none of this is a statement about what any lender will lend on your property.
How does the valuer test your lease and rental income?
The valuer tests the lease income against the market rather than accepting the passing rent at face value. Contract rent, market rent, incentives, expiry, options, outgoings and vacancy risk can all change the income the valuation supports.
These are the valuation profession's definitions for rental advice: face rent is the rent shown on a lease, and effective rent is the actual liability for rent after incentives such as rent-free periods, landlord fitout or cash are taken into account. Where contract rent differs from market rent, the valuer considers both and how the difference unwinds over the lease term; above-market rent does not automatically mean the whole lease rent is capitalised forever. Who the tenant is matters as well, which is how your tenant changes the loan even before the rent is read.
The time left on the lease is the other half of the test. A longer secure lease can support value because it gives a buyer more income certainty; a short lease tail, an upcoming expiry, vacancy risk or rent above market can increase the risk around the adopted income and yield. On a multi-tenant property, WALE means weighted average lease expiry: it summarises how far away the lease expiries sit across the property's income rather than looking at one tenancy in isolation. Some lenders also ask for a vacant possession value where a lease is close to expiry and the leased and vacant figures could differ materially. See how lease expiry and WALE can affect the loan. Where the lease is the main evidence a lender relies on, lease doc loans put even more weight on the valuer's rent read. For a closer look at passing rent, incentives and lease tails, see how the valuer treats rent and incentives.
What the valuer reads from the lease
- Time left on the lease
- Rent and how it is reviewed
- Options to renew
- How outgoings are recovered
- Who the tenant is
What the valuer adjusts for
- Rent above market
- Incentives such as rent-free periods or fitout contributions
- Vacancy and time to re-let
- A tenant related to the owner
- A short lease tail
What if your own business is the tenant?
The valuer will usually value the building as if it were vacant. The professional guidance for mortgage security work says owner-occupied property, including property occupied by a related entity, is valued on a vacant possession basis unless the lender instructs otherwise. So a lease from one of your entities to your own business does not lift the value for lending, however strong the rent looks. Plan your deposit on the vacant possession figure, and see how owner-occupied and investment property are treated differently.
What should you send before the inspection?
Send these to the valuer before the inspection, so the report rests on your documents rather than on assumptions.
- Signed leases and every variation.
- A current rent roll.
- The latest outgoings statement.
- Details of any incentives or side letters.
- Any agreement for lease.
- Building, fire and compliance reports you already hold.
- Recent capital works, with invoices.
- Comparable sales or leasing evidence you know of, with addresses and dates.
Arrange access to every part of the building, including tenanted areas, and give tenants the notice their lease requires. The report records the quality of the information the valuer relied on, so gaps in your documents show up in the report the lender reads.
Sources: Australian Property Institute, AVGP 301 Rental Valuations and Advice v2.0 s4.0, effective 1 July 2023. Read 25 September 2026. Australian Property Institute, ANZVGP 112 ss4.0, 5.3 and 5.8, issued 18 December 2024. Read 25 September 2026.
Who orders the valuation, who pays, and can you see it?
The lender orders the valuation, usually from its own panel, and the borrower usually pays for it as part of the application. You can often get a copy: if you are a small business customer of a bank that subscribes to the Banking Code of Practice and you paid for the valuation, the bank has committed to give you the report and the valuer's instructions.
Under clause 97 of the Banking Code of Practice 2025, where a subscribing bank has received a valuation of a commercial or agricultural real property which you have paid for, it will provide a copy of that valuation and the related valuer instruction, except where enforcement proceedings have commenced. The bank may ask you to acknowledge in writing that you accept its reasonable limitations on how you use the valuation. Clauses 95 and 96 commit the bank to fair and transparent valuation processes and to explaining the purpose of the valuation, and clause 98 to appointing only appropriately qualified and experienced valuers who are members of professional organisations which abide by a similar code of practice.
The Code's Part E treats a business customer as a Small Business if the customer, or its Business Group (if applicable), had an annual turnover of less than $10 million in the previous financial year and has fewer than 100 full-time equivalent employees. Non-bank and private lenders, and banks that do not subscribe, are not bound by these commitments. Ask for a copy in writing before you pay.
How much does a lender's commercial valuation cost, and how long does it take?
There is no single national fee or fixed turnaround in the mortgage-security guidance or Banking Code. The quote and timing depend on the property, location, number of leases, complexity, access and the lender's panel process. Before the lender orders it, ask for the fee, the expected inspection date, the expected report date and whether any rush fee applies. If you are under contract, compare that timetable with the finance-condition date rather than assuming the valuation will fit inside it.
What happens between ordering the valuation and approval?
The valuation runs in six steps, and the report goes to the lender before it reaches you:
- The lender instructs a valuer, usually from its panel and sometimes through a panel manager, and confirms who pays.
- The valuer contacts you or your agent for access and documents.
- The valuer inspects the property and analyses sales and rental evidence.
- The report goes to the lender, not to you.
- The lender reads it against its policy and sets the loan amount and conditions.
- You ask for your copy, in writing.
The same questions come up when refinancing to a new lender, because the new lender usually orders its own report. Where the property is sold with a trading business, the report may be one of the going concern valuations that value the business and the property together. If you are unsure which rules apply to you, check where you stand before a report is ordered.
| Question | General position | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Who chooses the valuer? | The lender appoints one, usually from its panel and sometimes through a panel manager. Code banks commit to qualified, experienced valuers who belong to a professional body with a similar code | Ask who is on the panel and roughly how long the report will take |
| Who pays? | Usually the borrower, as part of the application | The fee before it is ordered, and whether it is refundable if the loan does not proceed |
| Can you get a copy? | Yes, at a Code bank, if you are a Small Business customer and you paid for it. That includes the valuer instruction. It does not apply once enforcement has started | Your lender's policy if it is not a Code bank |
| Can you use your own valuer? | A lender cannot rely on a report you ordered until the valuer consents in writing and reissues it to that lender | Ask the lender before you order anything |
| How long does it stay current? | The value is as at the valuation date, normally the inspection date; how long a lender accepts it is lender policy | Ask the lender how old a report it will accept |
| Can it go to another lender? | Only with the valuer's written consent and a reissued report; a new lender usually orders its own | Ask both lenders before you pay twice |
Sources: Australian Banking Association, Banking Code of Practice 2025 cl 95 to 98 and Part E, commenced 28 February 2025. Read 25 September 2026. Australian Property Institute, ANZVGP 112 ss3.0, 4.1 and 4.2, issued 18 December 2024. Read 25 September 2026.
What happens after the valuation report comes back?
The lender reads the report alongside the rest of the credit file. A supportive valuation can still leave servicing or other credit conditions to clear; a low value or adverse risk comment can reduce the amount available, add conditions or stop the proposed structure from fitting policy. The report affects the security decision, while the lender still makes the lending decision.
What if the value supports the loan?
Expect conditions rather than a clean yes. Recommendations in the report, such as a building, fire or environmental report, usually become conditions of approval, so order them early if settlement is close. Ask for your copy of the report at the same time, while it is current.
What if the valuation comes in below the price?
If the lender accepts a value below the purchase price, the available loan can fall because its LVR is being applied to a smaller recognised value. The contract price does not fall automatically, so the difference can become extra cash, extra security or a price renegotiation. Start with the report's explanation of the value and the sale price, because that tells you what evidence a review would need to answer. The usual options are:
- More of your own funds to cover the gap.
- A renegotiated price, using the valuation as evidence with the vendor.
- Additional security, such as putting a second property behind the loan.
- A review of the report with evidence the valuer did not have, covered below.
- A different lender whose policy fits the property better, bearing in mind the new lender will usually order its own valuation.
If you have signed a contract, the finance-clause date keeps running while you work through these. A low valuation does not rewrite the contract by itself, and whether a finance condition protects you depends on its wording and the transaction. Ask your solicitor early whether an extension or other step is needed, and talk to a broker before the date passes, not after. The options are set out in more detail in covering a valuation shortfall at settlement.
Can you challenge a lender's commercial valuation?
You cannot change the valuer's figure yourself, because the report is addressed to the lender. A useful review request is evidence-led: identify any factual error, give the lender genuinely comparable recent sales or leasing evidence, provide missing signed leases or variations, and explain exactly which assumption or input you want checked. Ask the lender to request a review or whether it will order a second valuation. Whether it does either is lender policy. Banks that subscribe to the Banking Code have committed to fair and transparent valuation processes, which is a reason to ask, not a promise of a different figure.
What if settlement runs past the report's date?
The value is stated as at the valuation date, and each lender decides how old a report it will accept. If approval or settlement slips, ask the lender early for its limit on report age, and whether an update from the original valuer will do or a fresh inspection is needed, so a new inspection does not land on top of your settlement date.
When does a lender revalue during the loan, and what if the numbers move?
A lender can seek a new valuation when the facility terms and its review process allow it, including on a refinance or limit increase and, for some facilities, at a periodic review or after a material change to the security. The loan contract matters: there is no single revaluation timetable that applies to every commercial loan.
For market context, the Reserve Bank's March 2026 Financial Stability Review reported that valuations increased across most commercial real estate markets over 2025, and that demand for prime office space is supporting increased valuations and rents in the office sector. That is market context only, and it says nothing about any one property.
Revaluation risk sits with the individual building and its lease. A tenant leaving or a lease running down can move one property's value whatever the wider market is doing, and the guidance lets the valuer flag in the original report the risks that would justify reassessing the security if they happen. If a new value pushes the loan past a ratio in your facility, read what the facility lets the lender do, and see what happens after a covenant breach. The ratio is one kind of loan covenant, and your letter of offer sets out how it is tested.
Does a lower commercial valuation automatically mean you have to repay part of the loan?
No universal rule says a lower valuation by itself automatically requires immediate repayment. The consequence comes from the facility agreement: for example, an LVR covenant, review event, default provision or security clause may give the lender particular rights if the value falls or a covenant is breached. A lower value can therefore trigger a review, a request to reduce debt or provide more security, or another contractual remedy, but the valuation alone does not tell you which consequence applies. Read the facility terms and get legal advice on the contract if the position is material.
What can trigger a revaluation?
- A review clause in your facility.
- A tenant leaving or a lease nearing expiry.
- Asking to borrow more.
- Damage, or contamination on the security.
- Missed repayments.
Sources: Reserve Bank of Australia, Financial Stability Review, March 2026, published 19 March 2026. Read 25 September 2026.
Frequently Asked Questions
The lender instructs a valuer, usually from its panel, who inspects the property and reports market value at a stated date, the supporting evidence, the main risks and an estimated marketing period. The lender then separately applies its own LVR, servicing and credit policy.
The basis of value and assumptions, the value and the sales and rental evidence behind it, a risk analysis, an estimated marketing period, a summary of the leases and income relied on, and any recommendations for further reports.
Comparable sales and rents, the lease and tenant, the remaining lease term, outgoings, condition, zoning and use, and how easily the property would sell or re-let.
That is set by the lender, not by the valuer. The lender uses the value it accepts in its loan to value ratio calculation, then applies its own property, servicing, transaction and credit rules. The maximum varies by lender and property type and can be lower for specialised property.
Usually the borrower pays, as part of the application. The cost depends on the property and the work involved, so ask for the fee before the valuation is ordered and whether it is refundable if the loan does not go ahead.
If you are a small business customer of a bank that subscribes to the Banking Code and you paid for it, the bank has committed to give you the valuation and the valuer's instructions, unless enforcement has started. Other lenders set their own policy.
You can order one, but a lender cannot rely on it until the valuer consents in writing and reissues the report to that lender. Ask the lender first.
There is no universal turnaround. It depends on the property, access, complexity, the valuer's workload and how quickly the leases and other documents reach the valuer. Ask for the expected inspection and report dates when it is ordered, and if you are under contract, check both against your finance-clause date.
The value is as at the valuation date, normally the day of inspection. How long a lender will accept it is lender policy, so ask your lender before relying on an older report.
Not by design. A mortgage security valuation ordinarily reports market value on its stated basis and assumptions; it is not meant to be an automatic discount to the purchase price. The result can differ from the price because the valuer weighs the contract against broader sales, rental, lease and property evidence, and the same applies when a valuation is ordered under a purchase contract.
A valuation below the purchase price can reduce the amount available under the lender's LVR policy. The resulting shortfall may need to come from your own funds, a renegotiated price, additional security or another loan structure, as the worked arithmetic in covering a valuation shortfall at settlement shows.
You cannot change the valuer's figure yourself, because the report is addressed to the lender. You can give the lender evidence the valuer may not have had, such as comparable sales or signed leases, and ask it to request a review or order a second valuation. Whether it does is lender policy.
A lender's valuation is a market-value and security-risk report, not the lending decision itself. The valuer reports value at a stated date, the evidence and assumptions behind it, the main risks and an estimated marketing period. The lender then applies its own LVR, servicing and credit policy. A low accepted value can reduce the available loan even when the business otherwise services the debt.
Key takeaway: test valuation risk before signing, send the complete lease and property evidence before inspection, ask for the report, and have a shortfall plan before your finance date.
FBAA Accredited
