Existing Use Rights: Can You Borrow Against a Non-Conforming Property?

Existing Use Rights: Can You Borrow Against a Non-Conforming Property?

Existing use rights let a business use outlast a zoning change. How lenders value a non-conforming property, rebuild risk and what to check first.

Existing Use Rights Commercial Loans | Switchboard Finance
Switchboard Finance Property Lending Hub

Existing Use Rights · Non-Conforming Use · Commercial Property Loan

Existing Use Rights: Can You Borrow Against a Non-Conforming Property?

A common belief is that existing use rights mean you can always rebuild what is there. They do not. They let a lawful use carry on, and lenders price the gap between that use and what the zone allows today.

Published 20 November 2026 / Reviewed 20 November 2026 / Nick Lim, FBAA Accredited Finance Broker / General information only

Quick Answer

Existing use rights let a lawful business use carry on after the zoning changes, and some lenders will lend against such a property, but they value it on what it could be used for if the right were lost, so the loan is often smaller. Expect a cautious valuation and a lower loan-to-value ratio on a commercial property loan secured on a non-conforming site.

Also called: non-conforming use; existing lawful use (the Queensland term, under the Planning Act 2016). The labels differ by state, but each describes a use the current zone would not allow that carries on because it was lawful before the change.

What are existing use rights?

Existing use rights are a planning protection that lets a use of land carry on after a new zone or planning control would prohibit it, as long as the use was lawful before the change. The classic examples are a corner shop or a pub in a street later zoned residential, or a house left standing in an area rezoned for industry.

Two features matter most for a borrower. First, existing use rights run with the land, not with the owner, so a buyer can inherit them. Second, the person relying on the right has to prove it. Yarra City Council's guide to existing use rights sets out the Victorian position under Clause 63 of the planning scheme: the use must have been lawful, either under a permit or as a use that needed none, and the owner carries the burden of showing it has continued.

A property that relies on these rights is a non-conforming use property. That label is what a valuer and a lender's credit team react to, because it tells them the current income depends on a right that can be lost.

How do you check a property has existing use rights?

You check a property has existing use rights by gathering evidence that the use was lawful when it started and has run without a break since, then confirming the council accepts that evidence. Do this before you sign, not after the valuer asks.

  • Planning certificate or property report. Shows the current zone and overlays, which tells you whether the present use is permitted or relies on existing use rights.
  • Council records. Old permits, endorsed plans and any earlier ruling on the use.
  • Evidence of continuous use. The Yarra guide lists rates notices, utility and insurance records, invoices, leases, old directory listings, advertisements and aerial photographs. In Victoria, proof of continuous use over around fifteen years is treated as sufficient, at the time of writing.
  • Certificate of compliance. In Victoria, council guidance notes a certificate of compliance can confirm that a use is lawful, which gives a valuer something firmer than a vendor's word.
  • Contract disclosures. Read the vendor's statement and planning disclosures with your solicitor. Easements, covenants and anything built over the boundary are covered in our insight on easements and encroachments on title.

What lenders actually look at first is the zoning on the planning certificate. If the present use is not on the permitted list, the next question is always "where is the proof of existing use rights?", and a thin file slows the deal.

How do lenders and valuers treat a non-conforming property?

Lenders and valuers treat a non-conforming property as security whose current use could end, so the property is often valued on what the zone allows as well as on its present use, and the lender sets its limit off the more cautious figure. How lenders class a property by its zoning and use in the first place is covered in our guide to non-residential property loans; here the question is what the planning status does to the loan.

Three things drive the lender's answer:

  • Saleability. A lender asks who would buy the property if it had to sell. A buyer pool limited to operators of one use is smaller, and the security is discounted for it.
  • Value under the permitted use. A shop in a residential zone might be worth more or less as a house. The valuer reports both where they can, and the lender reads the gap.
  • Income reliance. If the loan is serviced by rent from the non-conforming use, losing the right removes the income and the value at the same time.

The practical result is often a smaller loan, varies by lender: a lower maximum loan-to-value ratio, a shorter term, or a referral to a specialist lender. Some major banks decline these properties outright, while some non-bank lenders and private lenders will look at them with full evidence. If the business is sold with the property, the lender may also look at it as a going concern. Our guide to what lenders test in a commercial property valuation explains the wider valuation process.

Can you rebuild if the building is damaged or destroyed?

You may not be able to rebuild a non-conforming building after damage or destruction, because rebuild is not automatic: existing use rights protect a use, and replacing the building is new work that usually needs a planning permit assessed under the planning scheme of the day. This is the risk most buyers miss and most lenders price.

Each state handles it differently, and some planning schemes allow a use to resume in a rebuilt building only within set limits or after an application. The detail sits in the planning scheme and with the council, so confirm it for the specific site with a planning lawyer or consultant before you rely on it.

What does the lender do with rebuild risk?

The lender treats rebuild risk as a value risk. If a fire could leave you with land you can only use for what the zone allows, the valuer considers that downside, and the lender may ask how the insurance responds. Insurance that pays to reinstate a building does not, on its own, give you the planning right to reinstate it. Our post on property insurance requirements for a loan covers what lenders ask of the policy itself.

How are existing use rights lost?

Existing use rights are usually lost when the use stops for a period of non-use, as the planning scheme sets it, or when the use changes to something else. Once lost, the property is limited to what the zone allows.

In Victoria, at the time of writing, the Yarra guide states the rights end if the use stops for two years or more, or stops for periods adding up to two years within any three years. A change of use also ends them: the guide's example is a dwelling with existing use rights that becomes a café in a commercial area and cannot later go back to being a dwelling. In NSW, an existing use is presumed abandoned if it stops for a continuous period of 12 months, under section 4.66 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979, unless the owner shows otherwise; Lismore City Council's existing use rights fact sheet sets out the 12-month rule. Other states set their own periods and tests, so check the local scheme.

For a buyer, the danger is a vacant property. A shop that has sat empty between tenants may already be close to, or past, the limit. Ask how long it has been vacant, and get evidence of when the use last ran.

Should a business owner buy a property that relies on existing use rights?

A business owner should buy a property that relies on existing use rights only when the right is proven, the use is running, the building is sound, and the loan still works at a cautious valuation. Use the table as a decision tree: a weak answer on any row is a reason to stop and check before you commit.

Buying a property that relies on existing use rights: what should you check, and what does it mean for the loan? (November 2026)
Question Where you find the answer What it changes for the lender
Is the use lawful now? Planning certificate, council records, permits, a certificate of compliance where available No proof usually means no loan on the present use, or a valuation on the permitted use only
Has it run without a break? Rates, utility, insurance and trading records, leases, vacancy history A recent gap raises the risk the right has lapsed; expect more questions and a more cautious limit
Is the building likely to need rebuilding? Building inspection, age and condition, any compliance notices An old or tired building adds rebuild risk, which the valuer may reflect in value
Do you plan works or a new use? The council and a planning consultant, before you sign Plans that depend on a permit you do not yet hold are not counted; the lender lends on what exists
Who will buy it after you? Local agent advice, sales of similar non-conforming sites A narrow buyer pool usually lowers the maximum loan-to-value ratio, varies by lender

Sources: Yarra City Council, Existing use rights (EUR) and planning permits, last updated date not shown. Lismore City Council, Existing use rights fact sheet, last updated date not shown. Both read 20 November 2026.

Keep going

  • Council records or a certificate confirm the use
  • The use is running today, with records
  • The building is sound and insured
  • The loan works at the cautious valuation

Stop and check

  • Only the vendor's word that the use is allowed
  • The property has sat vacant for a long stretch
  • The price assumes you can rebuild or expand
  • The deal only works at the full asking value

If you will occupy the property with your own business, read our guide to passive versus owner-operated commercial property, because an owner-occupied non-conforming site is assessed on your business's ability to pay as well as on the property.

Can you expand or change the use later?

You can sometimes expand or change the use of a property with existing use rights, but works, extensions and any intensification of the use usually need a planning permit, and the council assesses them against the planning scheme. Existing use rights protect what is there; they do not promise growth.

A change to a use the zone does allow is usually the easiest path, but it ends the existing use rights for good. Expanding the non-conforming use is harder and depends on the state's rules and the council. Where a mixed residential and business layout is part of the plan, our guide to mixed-use property loans explains how lenders treat that kind of security.

As a rule, the lender funds the property as it stands and treats any planned works as a later question. If you want a view on how a lender is likely to treat a specific site, check eligibility with the planning certificate and evidence of use in hand, and see how commercial property loans work before you make an offer.

Existing use rights let a lawful use outlast a zoning change, and they run with the land. Lenders will often still fund a non-conforming property, but they value it partly on what the zone allows, discount it for a narrower buyer pool and rebuild risk, and usually lend less. The rights can be lost through a period of non-use or a change of use, and they do not give you an automatic right to rebuild or expand.

Key takeaway: prove the right, confirm the use is running and test the loan at a cautious valuation before you sign.

Frequently Asked Questions

A commercial property that relies on existing use rights is usually valued on its present use and on what the current zone allows, and lenders tend to lend off the more cautious figure. The valuer also weighs the narrower buyer pool and the risk the right is lost. See how lenders approach a valuation for the wider method.

If a building that relies on existing use rights burns down, the right to keep the use does not automatically give you the right to rebuild. Rebuilding is usually new work that needs a planning permit, and the rules differ by state and planning scheme. Lenders price this risk, which is one reason the loan-to-value ratio is often lower.

In Victoria, existing use rights lapse if the use stops for two years or more, or for periods adding up to two years within any three years, at the time of writing. A change of use also ends them. Confirm the position with the council before you buy, and read what lenders test in a commercial property valuation once a use changes.

You prove existing use rights by showing the use was lawful when it started and has continued, using permits, endorsed plans, rates and utility records, leases, invoices and photographs. The owner carries the burden of proof, and in Victoria a certificate of compliance can confirm the use. A lender will want this evidence before it accepts the property as security.

Some banks will lend on a property with existing use rights and some will not, and those that do usually lend less against it. Non-bank and private lenders are often more open where the right is well documented. A broker can match the property to a lender for a commercial property loan that accepts non-conforming security.

Nick Lim

Nick Lim

Broker, Switchboard Finance

0483 980 567 / [email protected]

FBAA FBAA Accredited
Previous
Previous

Low Doc Home Loans in Melbourne and Victoria for the Self-Employed

Next
Next

Easements and Encroachments: Will a Lender Still Fund Your Property?